FPL Gameweek 5 Preview — First XI, Captaincy Verdict, Transfer Thesis & The Differential Nobody Has Thought Of
Greetings, pupils, and welcome back.
I scored 77 points in Gameweek 4. Normally this would be the part where I straighten the gown, adjust the spectacles and explain that another perfectly respectable week has demonstrated the benefits of listening to your professor. Unfortunately, my bench scored 38 points. Thirty-eight.
Verbruggen scored eight. Kevin Schade scored 15. Leif Davis scored 14. Harry Maguire added one, presumably because even the universe felt 39 would have been unnecessarily cruel.
So while João Pedro rewarded the captaincy with 24 points, Calvert-Lewin scored 10 and Haaland returned nine, I spent much of the weekend staring at four little boxes at the bottom of my screen and wondering whether Fantasy Premier League offers a degree in self-sabotage.
The worst part is that none of these players were obscure punts. Schade scored twice at Bournemouth. Davis produced a goal and an assist at Crystal Palace. They were already in my squad. I simply placed them somewhere their points could do absolutely no harm to anybody.
Naturally, my immediate reaction was to press the Wildcard button and rebuild civilisation. I have since been restrained.
The First XI
The first lesson from Gameweek 4 is very simple: Kevin Schade is not sitting on my bench again.
After scoring twice at Bournemouth, Schade now has three Premier League goals this season. I already owned the differential. I simply chose to admire him from a safe distance while his points accumulated somewhere they could not help me.
That will not be happening again.
The midfield is Morgan Rogers, Bruno Fernandes, Rayan Cherki, Kevin Schade and Diego Gómez. Rogers stays because he continues to return, Cherki gets Sunderland at home, Bruno gets Fulham and Schade has earned his promotion from the naughty step.
At the back, I am making one change.
Harry Maguire leaves. Neco Williams comes in.
Williams has played every minute of Forest’s opening four league matches, has collected 17 FPL points and remains only £5.0m. More importantly for this week, Forest host Coventry. That is exactly the sort of fixture I want to attack with a defender who is being used as a wing-back under Oliver Glasner. He goes straight into the First XI alongside Konsa and Calafiori.
And yes, that means Leif Davis goes back to the bench one week after scoring 14 points there.
I appreciate the danger.
But Fantasy Premier League cannot be played by permanently starting everybody who punished you the previous week. Everton away is a perfectly reasonable fixture for Davis, but I prefer Forest’s clean-sheet opportunity against Coventry. If Davis scores another 14 points from the bench, this column will be suspended pending an internal investigation.
Up front it is Haaland and Calvert-Lewin, with João Pedro’s place dependent on the final injury news.
The Transfer Thesis
There is one transfer this week:
Harry Maguire → Neco Williams
And for once, I am not overcomplicating it.
Maguire has fallen to £4.9m after starting the season at £5.0m, while Williams remains £5.0m. With £0.1m sitting in the bank, the move uses the entire budget. The attraction is partly Gameweek 5, but not entirely.
Forest host Coventry this weekend and Williams has played all 360 available Premier League minutes. He is operating in a system that asks its wing-backs to provide width and attacking threat, which gives him another route to points beyond simply waiting for a clean sheet.
After that, Forest face Crystal Palace, Arsenal, Ipswich, Brentford and Manchester City. There are difficult fixtures in there, obviously, but Ipswich and Brentford also give Williams further opportunities before we need to reconsider the position.
Most importantly, I am still not Wildcarding. Gameweek 4 produced 77 points with another 38 on the bench. That is not evidence of a squad requiring demolition. If anything, it suggests I have enough useful players and simply require the revolutionary tactical innovation of putting the correct ones on the pitch.
So Maguire becomes Williams.
One transfer.
No hit.
No Wildcard.
The Savant has finally discovered restraint.
The Captaincy Verdict
Erling Haaland | Manchester City | £15.5m
Occasionally FPL demands courage.
Occasionally it demands imagination.
And occasionally Manchester City play Sunderland at home and you should stop trying to demonstrate how clever you are.
Haaland has scored four goals across the last three Gameweeks and leads every player this season for both shots inside the box and big chances. Sunderland have kept only one clean sheet in four league matches and arrive at the Etihad after European involvement. The official FPL Scout has also given Haaland the armband in its Gameweek 5 selection.
There are interesting alternatives. Morgan Gibbs-White hosts a Coventry side who have not scored a Premier League goal yet, while Calvert-Lewin faces a Palace defence that has been alarmingly generous. But this is not a week for me to wander into a laboratory and start mixing liquids together.
Haaland captain.
Bruno vice.
The Differential
Kevin Schade | Brentford | £6.1m
Yes, him.
The man I brilliantly placed on my bench immediately before he scored twice and collected 15 points. Schade has three goals already this season and remains owned by only around six per cent of managers. That normally makes him the sort of player I would spend 400 words telling you to buy.
Conveniently, I already own him.
More importantly, I actually like the Chelsea fixture.
Chelsea have conceded nine goals in four league matches, at least two in every game. Brentford, meanwhile, are dangerous in transition and rank second in the league for expected goals from set pieces. This is precisely the sort of match where Schade’s pace can become very uncomfortable very quickly. Will Chelsea dominate possession? Almost certainly.
Could they win comfortably? Of course.
Could Schade also spend 70 minutes doing very little before suddenly appearing behind the defence and ruining my Friday evening if I bench him again? I am not conducting that experiment twice.
He starts.
The Savant’s Verdict
So Gameweek 5 is about correction rather than reconstruction. Neco Williams comes in for Maguire and goes straight into the XI. Schade is released from the bench after scoring 15 points in captivity. Davis returns to reserve duty despite his 14-point protest, Haaland gets the armband and the Wildcard remains untouched.
If the bench outscores the First XI by 38 points again, there will be no Gameweek 6 article. There will simply be a statement from my representatives.
Class is in session.
I analyse in private. You should browse that way too. Secure your connection with Surfshark.
Some links in this article may be affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
